Summary of research on how court decisions protect or limit socio-environmental protection, carried out in the Socio-environmental Litigation course at UnB (2026.2). The analysis brings together five cases recorded using the course's emblematic-case checklist and an extended table of rulings on the sun coral.
Presentation
Cases analyzed
- ACO 1,100 (STF) - Ibirama-La Klãnõ Indigenous Land, the "marco temporal" thesis and territorial demarcation.
- AG 0808528 (TRF5) - sun coral, marine bioinvasion and proof of causation.
- ADI 7,095 (STF) - mineral coal and a just energy transition.
- ACP 1016202 (JF-AM) - repeal of the sugarcane agroecological zoning in the Amazon and the Pantanal.
- ACP 0100675 (TJRN) - Pirangi do Sul dunes, permanent preservation area, demolition and enforcement.
Vocabulary: ten concepts for reading the cases
Procedural and substantive categories used in the analysis.
- Original Civil Action (ACO) - action within the original jurisdiction of the STF (art. 102, I, f, CF), available in federative conflicts, such as that of ACO 1,100.
- Direct Action of Unconstitutionality (ADI) - instrument of concentrated, abstract constitutional review of a law or normative act.
- Public Civil Action (ACP) - collective action under Law 7,347/1985 for the protection of diffuse rights, such as the environment.
- Interlocutory appeal (agravo de instrumento) - appeal against an interlocutory decision, such as one granting provisional relief (art. 1,015, I, CPC).
- Mandatory review (remessa necessária) - compulsory re-examination by the appellate court of a judgment rendered against the Public Treasury (art. 496, CPC).
- Provisional relief (tutela provisória) - decision based on summary review, grounded on the likelihood of the right and the risk of harm (art. 300, CPC).
- Referendum (referendo) - confirmation by the full Court of an interim measure granted individually by the rapporteur.
- Ratio decidendi - the determining ground of the decision; it is what the checklist examines.
- Marco temporal (time-frame thesis) - thesis that conditioned Indigenous land rights on occupation as of 10/5/1988; rejected by the STF in Theme 1,031 (RE 1,017,365).
- Permanent Preservation Area (APP) - area protected by the Forest Code and by CONAMA resolutions, such as dunes (Res. 303/2002).
Socio-environmental litigation and health
Possible research areas that bring socio-environmental litigation and the valuation of environmental damage closer to health topics.
Health components of environmental damage
- impact of environmental damage on human health;
- healthcare costs and burden of disease associated with environmental exposure;
- pesticides, contaminants and other toxic exposures;
- effects on exposed workers and communities;
- quality of water, food and soil as determinants of health;
- health redress in environmental litigation, with population monitoring, biomonitoring and health follow-up;
- a One Health approach, integrating human, environmental and animal health.
Research areas in law, health and the environment
- Environmental health and rights - impacts of pollution, contamination and environmental degradation on health and on access to rights.
- Pesticides and exposed populations - health risks to rural workers, nearby communities and consumers.
- Valuation of environmental damage with a health component - how effects on health, quality of life and healthcare costs are factored into the redress of environmental damage.
- Socio-environmental litigation in health - mapping of court cases involving contamination, toxic exposure, water, soil, food and public health.
- One Health - integration of human health, animal health, the environment and agricultural production.
- Risk communication - accessible materials for patients and communities on exposure to contaminants and environmental risks.
- Education on socio-environmental rights - workshops and materials for patients, students and communities on the right to health and to a balanced environment.
- Research with social participation - accounts and experiences of patients and communities incorporated into studies on environmental impacts.
- Toxicology and scientific evidence - epidemiological and toxicological evidence brought closer to legal analysis and policymaking.
- Inequalities and environmental justice - which groups bear the greatest burden of exposure, illness and difficulty in accessing redress.
- Outreach projects - activities with exposed communities, videos, booklets, courses and discussion circles.
- Academic output - articles, undergraduate theses, undergraduate research and research projects involving Law, Health and the Environment.
